I'm wondering what is the best way to approach this dilemma. There is a student in my after school program who has trouble summarizing stories. Phonologically she is a great reader, but how can I help her retain meaning from the story.
I think that it's always best to work on talking first, and I find social circle one of the best places to do this. If you don't already, start your class with social circle, where you say hello, shake hands, perhaps play a quick game, then let students talk about whatever they like. This "telling of stories" is crucial. If you find that you have students who can't tell you what they did last night - the 'We went to McDonalds and I ate a hamburger and then we played in the playground and I jumped in the plastic balls" then for me it's the sign of real language issues - the kid should be referred to a speech therapist.
But retelling a story should be a teachers bread and butter - who the characters where, what the setting was, what the problem was and what the solution was for fiction.
She may just need practice. Does she have the same problem when she listens to a story?