I'm wondering if anybody has used Lively and if so what they think of it. How do you compare it to Second Life (pros vs cons). It appears to have a much smoother/crisper cartoony look then Second Life's pixelated graphics.


Views: 46

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Really surprised how plain, lightweight, and un-interactive it is (given that its a 3D virtual world !) .. Being "Google" they could have really done this right & leveraged Google Earth, Sketchup, their 3D warehouse, etc. .... Linden Labs has to be breathing a huge sigh of relief if this is all Google has planned for their 3D web strategy.
Yea, who knows, although Google is pretty smart and it is barely our of alpha mode.

I'm curious to see how their new phone the Android stacks up to the iPhone.

To be honest I always found Second Life to be buggy and very uncompelling. In that regard my reaction to Lively was almost completely identical to the first time I fired up SL. "This is it? Hmmm....moving on." Perhaps I'm not a target audience though. The only reason spaces like this compel me would be that it would make for an awesome arena to hold discussions for an online classroom. Allowing students to express themselves through their avatars and whatnot. But yeah, the actual program was limited, buggy, and generally not worth spending much time in.
It obviously doesn't have the level of control or sophistication of Second Life - it couldn't and be that accessible.

It's early days yet -- the interface with YouTube brings in videos quickly and the controls, while they take getting used to are - according to other avatars I talked with - very similar to the Sims. Some people were comparing some of the template spaces to EverQuest and World of Warcraft -- so not hard to see who the target market is.

I didn't like the lack of control I had over animations. When I typed in lol - my character went off into shrill hysterical laughter. When I typed Hi she trilled Hi--eee in a loud saccharine voice.

I'm going to take a wait and see approach. For me, Second Life has several advantages from an education and communication perspective. The level of control, the ability to build from scratch, the level of realism balanced with whimsy -- but I think it's comparing apples and oranges.

Lively seems to be more about the chat and having fun -- although I'll admit to being turned off my first time in yesterday when a male avatar repeatedly punched a female avatar in the face and was laughing as it happened. I've persisted and had some interesting conversations this morning. Here's a quick and dirty video:
Wow, thanks so much for the in depth review on this site. When I watched the demo video on their site, I was a little turned off when I saw avatars punching each other and all that.

As of right now, it does feel to be more geared towards kids in a gaming atmosphere even though it does have options to create a more realistic environment such as Second Life.
I like the idea, since it would cost a lot to buy an Island in Teen Second Life but it would be free to have my own classroom in Lively. However, one of the things I liked about Second Life was the ability to create stuff. You can't do that in Lively yet (if ever).

I may put a Lively room in my class Ning this fall.
Doesn't look like its mac compatible - so its a dud for me
Yea me too, but I'll give it a shot when it transfers over, of course, we can boot into Windows if we wanted to try it out, but it's not ideal for my district right now.



Win at School

Commercial Policy

If you are representing a commercial entity, please see the specific guidelines on your participation.





© 2024   Created by Steve Hargadon.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service