The best of the best?
Last Friday a colleague emailed me asked what would I say are the three best pieces of technology available to teachers? These questions really gave me pause to think about the technology I deal with everyday as an Instructional Technologist responsible for training teachers in the latest technology we have available. If I went back to the classroom tomorrow and was told I could take any three pieces of technology with me, what would I take?
In my response I assumed I would have a computer in my classroom with a high speed Internet connection and unlimited bandwidth. I would make sure that as the teacher I would have a laptop loaded with all the software I would need. With that in mind, here were my choices.
1. A ceiling mounted LCD projector. Having a LCD fundamentally changed the way I taught when I was in the classroom. I could bring in images, videos, simulation, and all kinds of interactive media to enhance my presentations and capture the attention of students. I had to rearrange my classroom, string cables and extension cords to get everything to work but it was worth it. Having a mounted projector would just make everything easier and neater.
2. A student response clicker system ranks side by side with the LCD projector. I used everything from thumbs up/thumbs downs to individual chalkboard to help me assess the learning and understanding of my students before, after, and during a lesson. A RF clicker system like Senteo, CPS, or Turning Point not only makes gathering this information easier, it also records the information so I can track each student’s progress. It would vital to readjusting individual lesson, or unit scope and sequencing to best meet my student’s needs. It would also allow me to track all students, reducing those students that never bring any attention to themselves but struggle with achievement. I want all my students to be successful and I want to know when they are getting it and when they need more help before the summative assessment is given.
3. An Interactive white board. If I was teaching elementary school, I would want a SmartBoard (paired with Senteo clickers) and if I was back in middle or high school I would want an Interwrite Board (paired with CPS clickers). Why the different configurations? The SmartBoard allows students to interact using their fingers. This tactile interaction is great for younger students. I like the Interwrite board because you have to use a pen device but with it you have much more precision because of a greater output resolution. This is very helpful when working with spreadsheets and other programs that require more precision. The Interwrite boards are very durable. This is important in middle school and high school where students often underestimate their strength. I have used both boards (and teach others both software packages) and both are fine products. I firmly believe that the use of an interactive board increasing time on task and enthusiasm for learning. Our students enter school with the concept that learning is also entertaining. Think of all the educational shows and programs for preschool students. We need to use this concept to continue the engagement of our students in the learning process.
So here are my three choices. I would love to hear what you think are best tools for a teachers right now.
In my response I assumed I would have a computer in my classroom with a high speed Internet connection and unlimited bandwidth. I would make sure that as the teacher I would have a laptop loaded with all the software I would need. With that in mind, here were my choices.
1. A ceiling mounted LCD projector. Having a LCD fundamentally changed the way I taught when I was in the classroom. I could bring in images, videos, simulation, and all kinds of interactive media to enhance my presentations and capture the attention of students. I had to rearrange my classroom, string cables and extension cords to get everything to work but it was worth it. Having a mounted projector would just make everything easier and neater.
2. A student response clicker system ranks side by side with the LCD projector. I used everything from thumbs up/thumbs downs to individual chalkboard to help me assess the learning and understanding of my students before, after, and during a lesson. A RF clicker system like Senteo, CPS, or Turning Point not only makes gathering this information easier, it also records the information so I can track each student’s progress. It would vital to readjusting individual lesson, or unit scope and sequencing to best meet my student’s needs. It would also allow me to track all students, reducing those students that never bring any attention to themselves but struggle with achievement. I want all my students to be successful and I want to know when they are getting it and when they need more help before the summative assessment is given.
3. An Interactive white board. If I was teaching elementary school, I would want a SmartBoard (paired with Senteo clickers) and if I was back in middle or high school I would want an Interwrite Board (paired with CPS clickers). Why the different configurations? The SmartBoard allows students to interact using their fingers. This tactile interaction is great for younger students. I like the Interwrite board because you have to use a pen device but with it you have much more precision because of a greater output resolution. This is very helpful when working with spreadsheets and other programs that require more precision. The Interwrite boards are very durable. This is important in middle school and high school where students often underestimate their strength. I have used both boards (and teach others both software packages) and both are fine products. I firmly believe that the use of an interactive board increasing time on task and enthusiasm for learning. Our students enter school with the concept that learning is also entertaining. Think of all the educational shows and programs for preschool students. We need to use this concept to continue the engagement of our students in the learning process.
So here are my three choices. I would love to hear what you think are best tools for a teachers right now.
-
Comment by David Kampmann on February 23, 2009 at 4:00pm
-
Those are great choices. If I had to replace one it would be number 3. I would pick access to laptops in the classroom. Obviously though, getting a smartboard or interwrite board would be easier to happen.
I don't know if other teachers have it, but I am using my Wacom tablet with the notebook feature of SmartBoard. It works pretty well.
-
Comment by Matt Townsley on February 23, 2009 at 5:41pm -
I think the answer to this question can only be determined by first knowing the teachers' content area and pedagogical knowledge. While a ceiling mounted video projector seems like a great add-on to any classroom (I wish I had one, to be honest), does it necessarily change the way students learn and teachers teach? One might go from lecturing on using a chalkboard to lecturing via PowerPoint and a smart board. Yes, these things are "cool," but even feedback from students in the building I teach in tells me that students eventually see through teachers using technology just for the sake of using it.
I'm not trying to rain on your parade here, Bob, but hoping this angle can add something to your conversation.
-
Comment by Bob.Snyder on February 23, 2009 at 6:20pm -
Such is the dilemma of technology, is it flash or fire. I would argue that the effectiveness of technology is related to a teachers willingness to change how they teach. You are right in recognizing that most powerpoints are just a fancy way to replace transparencies and an overhead. And that is because most teachers are more comforting trying to fit technology into their established teaching styles rather than to change teaching styles to better enhance the effectiveness of technology. For example as a science teacher I had students design and build catapults. Part of their research was using an interactive tool to "try" different configuration. This was highly effective because the students were actively involved in problem solving rather than listening to me lecture. I have English teachers that have more away from classroom discussions of books to using online discussion boards. To a teacher they are extremely excited about the results because all students must participate and all students have enough wait time to compose thoughtful responses (though not all do). Finally without a doubt the student response systems are valuable because they provide all students and the teacher with immediate feedback. Lessons can be adjusted, struggling students identified, and differentiation planned. Teachers do not have to rely on their gut feelings but have good data. Teachers will not be replaced by technology but we need to become effective and efficient users of technology. Our students need to see effective use of technology and need to become effective usersof technology. Here is link to a futurist view of how the world is changing. I don't agree with it all but I found the paradigm shifts interesting. http://www.slideshare.net/moravec/society-3-0-presentation
-
Comment by Matt Townsley on February 23, 2009 at 6:37pm
-
Right on, Bob. I like your emphasis on doing "new things" with technology rather than "old things" in "new ways."
-
Comment by Chelsie Sinsel on April 6, 2009 at 9:27am -
I like that you are incorporating three different aspects of technology rather than three types of technology that can be used for the same type of teaching. The clickers is an excellent idea that is recently appearing in classrooms. This is enjoyable for the students when they see that their opinion or answers are actually being recognized.
Comment
Commercial Policy
If you are representing a commercial entity, please see the specific guidelines on your participation.
The Fifth Year Anniversary Book Project!
Related Links & Events:
EdIncubator
EdIncubator" projects are designed to help education projects or initiatives build advisory councils with real educators, administrators, parents, and students giving real feedback. Current projects are below.
Groups interested in participating can contact Steve Hargadon directly.
Support:
Classroom 2.0 is a free site. You can support the network by making a donation (any amount):You can also support us by using our Amazon search link:
Thanks to support from:
Badge
About
Follow
Awards:
© 2012 Created by Steve Hargadon.
You need to be a member of Classroom 2.0 to add comments!
Join Classroom 2.0